點樣判斷間學校教得好唔好?
點樣判斷教學質素?
由外面睇一間學校教學質素好唔好其實好難——啲課程簡介同老師簡歷寫嚟寫去都差唔多,但你真正想知嘅嘢(即係我讀完會唔會有料到、考牌會唔會過),呢啲嘢係唔會寫喺課程大綱度嘅。不過有幾個實在啲嘅指標可以幫到手:
1. 執業試合格率(最貼近「成績表」嘅嘢)
California Acupuncture Board 會公佈每間學校嘅CALE(加州針灸執照考試)首次應考合格率,睇多年總數會比單一年份嘅數字有意義得多——一班人數少嘅話,一次重考就可以令個合格率上下擺動20到50個百分點,但人數多嗰班就幾乎唔會有咁大波動。根據五系中醫藥大學嘅TCM Education Guide整合資料(查詢日期:08/2026):
| 學校 | 2021-2025應考人數 (N) | 合格人數 | 累積合格率 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 五系中醫藥大學 | 169 | 145 | 85.8% |
| Acupuncture & Integrative Medicine College, Berkeley | 99 | 82 | 82.8% |
| Academy of Chinese Culture & Health Sciences | 88 | 73 | 83% |
| California University-Silicon Valley | 15(約一半為估算數字) | 11 | 73.3% |
五系中醫藥大學嘅應考人數喺呢班學校入面係最多、亦都最穩定嘅(每年都有26到42個人應考)——呢一點正正令佢嘅百分比更加可信,相比起某啲學校每年得幾個人應考,一個人嘅結果就可以令成個合格率大幅擺動。
2. 唔使睇成績表都可以判斷嘅結構性指標
| 指標 | 要留意啲乜 |
|---|---|
| 師資背景 | 資深導師有30年以上教學/執業經驗,包括喺中國本土嘅中醫院校同醫院受過訓練 |
| 班級人數 | 班size要細到你真係可以同老師一齊實務操作,唔係得坐喺講堂度聽書 |
| 臨床督導 | 畢業前要有由老師直接督導、實際接觸病人嘅診症時數,唔係淨係計課堂時數 |
| 認證資格 | 有冇專項課程認證(五系中醫藥大學嘅係ACAHM(美國中醫藥及針灸院校評審委員會)認證)——證明有外部機構審核師資同課程,唔係得學校自己講自己好 |
如果你想睇下具體有邊啲導師同佢哋嘅背景,五系中醫藥大學喺fivebranches.edu/faculty(查詢日期:08/2026)都有公開自己嘅師資名錄同診所架構資料。
你而家係諗緊比較緊兩三間具體嘅學校,定係想搞清楚應該由邊啲方面入手去睇?
資料來源
- Five Branches University — Accreditation Degrees Programs 查證 2026-08
- Oikos University — Cale Pass Rates Northern California 查證 2026-08
- Five Branches University — Faculty 查證 2026-08
Information Disclaimer
TEG compiles information from independent third-party sources, with source references and access dates provided where available. Five Branches University does not independently verify or guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or currency of third-party information or its summaries. Readers should confirm relevant details with the original sources or appropriate authorities before relying on them. To the fullest extent permitted by law, the University disclaims liability arising from reliance on such information.
最後審閱: