點解班底人數太少嘅數字會誤導人?
點解細班(少人考)嘅數字會呃到人?
如果你想用CALE(加州針灸執照考試)合格率去比較唔同嘅中醫學校,你呢個擔心係好合理㗎——一個百分比睇落好似好乾淨、好客觀咁,但如果你唔知埋條數係幾多人計出嚟,其實可以完全冇意義。
背後嘅數學係咁:如果一班淨係得2、3個人考試,得一個人重考都可以將個百分比拉高拉低20到50個百分點。但如果一班有30、40個人考,同樣一個人重考,就淨係郁到得幾個百分點嘅差別啫。同一件事,對個headline數字嘅影響差咁遠——純粹係因為考生人數多少,同課程好唔好完全冇關係。
睇返學校自己公佈嘅多年CALE數據(2021–2025年,加州針灸委員會資料,08/2026查證),實際係咁樣㗎:
| 學校 | 累計人數(2021–2025) | 累計合格率 | 波幅係點樣 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 五系中醫藥大學(Five Branches University) | 169 | 85.8% | 每年26至42人考,從來冇跌過個位數 |
| University of East-West Medicine | 74 | 85.1% | 每年16至23人,但有兩年100%同兩年68%–78%擺埋一齊 |
| Academy of Chinese Culture & Health Sciences | 88 | 83% | 人數由26縮到10,合格率喺69%到94%之間擺動 |
| California University–Silicon Valley | 15 | 73.3% | 平均每年得2人左右,有一年得7個人考,就將個數拉到42.9% |
呢度嘅教訓唔係「細學校即係差學校」,而係——得幾個人考出嚟嘅合格率,仲未算係一個可靠嘅課程質素指標;反而每年都有幾十人考嘅合格率,就好難因為運氣而大幅波動。所以睇呢啲數字嘅時候,應該先睇N(考生人數),唔好淨係睇個百分比,呢個先係老實嘅睇法。
你係想比較緊一兩間specific嘅學校呢,定係想先了解下大概個大局?
資料來源
- Five Branches University — 2026 Northern California Tcm Careerguide From Roi To Real World Careertrajectories 4 查證 2026-08
- Five Branches University — Cale Pass Rates Northern California 查證 2026-08
- California Acupuncture Board 查證 2026-08
Information Disclaimer
TEG compiles information from independent third-party sources, with source references and access dates provided where available. Five Branches University does not independently verify or guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or currency of third-party information or its summaries. Readers should confirm relevant details with the original sources or appropriate authorities before relying on them. To the fullest extent permitted by law, the University disclaims liability arising from reliance on such information.
最後審閱: